What each product actually is
Amp centers large-repo agentic edits with a commercial freemium desk that now spans local threads and remote Orbs. Dial selects capability modes; Orbs run unsupervised remote agents you can still steer.
Cline is an Apache-2.0 open-source coding agent for VS Code (also CLI/SDK/desktop surfaces in current vendor marketing): plan-and-act workflows, multi-file edits with diffs/checkpoints, bash execution, and BYOK model choice. Explicit approval stays the default control loop unless auto-approve is on.
Current surfaces (vendor-documented)
Amp (since the 2026-03-25 score date): Agents in Orbs (remote unsupervised machines); event-driven Orbs via webhooks; Dial customization — tune builtin modes and place custom plugin agents on the Dial; custom agents via Plugin API. Sources: https://ampcode.com/news/agents-in-orbs · https://ampcode.com/news/event-driven-orbs · https://ampcode.com/news/build-your-own-dial
Cline (since the 2026-03-25 score date): v4.0 (Jun 2026) migrates the VS Code extension onto the shared Cline SDK (same harness as CLI/Kanban/JetBrains) — Plan/Act, MCP, checkpoints, queued prompts, ClinePass/onboarding, plugins/marketplace; later staged rollout to 100% SDK extension (vendor Aug 2026). HITL approvals + BYOK remain the product thesis. Sources: https://github.com/cline/cline/releases/tag/v4.0.0 · https://cline.bot/blog/how-we-migrated-11-million-users-to-clines-biggest-harness-upgrade
Scoreboard (from existing reviews)
Amp (Score dated 2026-03-25): overall 85, speed 87, privacy 83, developer experience 84.
Cline (Score dated 2026-03-25): overall 84, speed 78, privacy 88, developer experience 86.
These figures come from the existing aicoolies reviews for each tool. On those published totals Amp leads overall and speed; Cline leads privacy and developer experience. Prefer fit and current product surfaces; use the table as supporting Score references with the dates above.
Workflow
Choose Amp for commercial agent desks with Orbs/Dial and Sourcegraph-line code intelligence. Choose Cline for editor-native HITL approvals, open-source runtime, and BYOK transparency.
Licensing and billing
Amp: freemium Megawatt/Gigawatt-style tiers + orb usage (catalog). Cline: Apache-2.0 at $0 for the tool; BYOK token costs paid to the model provider. Cite catalog/vendor; no invented plan math.





