What each product actually is
Amp centers large-repo agentic edits with a commercial freemium desk that now spans local threads and remote Orbs. Dial selects capability modes; Orbs run unsupervised remote agents you can still steer.
Codex is OpenAI’s multi-surface coding agent: managed app/cloud/review-style surfaces plus CLI/SDK/IDE paths. The buyer job is often “delegate or pair across OpenAI’s tools,” not only a single terminal multiplexer.
Current surfaces (vendor-documented)
Amp (since the 2026-03-25 score date): Agents in Orbs (remote unsupervised machines); event-driven Orbs via webhooks; Dial customization — tune builtin modes and place custom plugin agents on the Dial; custom agents via Plugin API. Sources: https://ampcode.com/news/agents-in-orbs · https://ampcode.com/news/event-driven-orbs · https://ampcode.com/news/build-your-own-dial
Codex (since the 2026-03-25 score date): CLI train through 0.154 — GPT-6 Astra picker/default story; experimental worktrees; Windows background daemon; agents dashboard / task tooling (Aug–Sep 2026). Sources: https://github.com/openai/codex/releases
Scoreboard (from existing reviews)
Amp (Score dated 2026-03-25): overall 85, speed 87, privacy 83, developer experience 84.
Codex (Score dated 2026-03-25): overall 80, speed 72, privacy 68, developer experience 79.
These figures come from the existing aicoolies reviews for each tool. On those published totals Amp leads across overall, speed, privacy, and developer experience. Prefer fit and current product surfaces (Orbs/Dial vs Astra/worktree/daemon); use the table as supporting Score references with the dates above.
Workflow
Choose Amp for codebase-intelligent local threads plus remote Orbs and Dial modes. Choose Codex for OpenAI multi-surface delegation and the newer CLI worktree/daemon direction.
Ecosystem and billing
Amp: freemium Megawatt/Gigawatt-style tiers + orb usage (catalog). Codex: managed surfaces via ChatGPT plans; CLI/SDK/IDE API-key usage on token rates. Cite catalog/vendor; no invented plan math.





