What Sets Them Apart
Composio and Smithery used to compete on managed connections for agents. That comparison ended on October 31, 2026, when Smithery shut down its connection-management services. Composio is a working integration platform; Smithery is a directory.
Composio
Composio says it connects agents to more than 1,500 apps and works with ChatGPT and Codex, Claude and Claude Code, Cursor and any MCP client. It handles authentication for you and stores credentials encrypted. The free Hobby plan includes 100,000 tool calls per month, with third-party paid tools billed separately. Composio states SOC 2 Type II compliance and offers Cloud, Private VPC and self-hosted Enterprise deployment with Helm and customer-managed keys. You can also add custom MCP servers at no charge.
Smithery
On October 31, 2026 Smithery shut down its hosted server URLs (run.tools and server.smithery.ai), the Smithery API, Connect and Toolbox, Smithery accounts and API keys, and deprecated its CLI and SDKs. Paid subscriptions were cancelled and charges since August 5, 2026 refunded. Arcade.dev had acquired Smithery on August 5, 2026. What remains is smithery.ai as a public, non-proxied MCP directory with a curated set of verified servers whose pages list the vendor's direct MCP URL.
The Bottom Line
If your agents need authenticated access to apps such as Gmail, Slack or GitHub, choose Composio (or Arcade, which Smithery now points to). Use Smithery's directory only to check which MCP servers exist and find vendors' direct URLs.




